Unfortunately, her reign came to a close at the end of WWII. Apparently, her extravagant lifestyle was heavily subsidized by Charles LeMaire (Hollywood designer), whose checks suddenly stopped. She tried an assortment of schemes to recoup her fortune. But, her luck ran out, forcing her into poverty.
It was at this point there was an unsuccessful attempt to convert her to a Jehovah Witness. She moved to Quechee, VT., but returned to Brattleboro six months later. There she came to rely on her old friends, especially her past bootlegging associates, for financial and moral support. In 1959, she returned to the Castle, only to find it so completely vandalized that she could never bring herself to return. The castle came to a fiery end on Oct. 20, 1962. Mrs. Charles LeMaire foreclosed on the property on July 16, 1963.
Destitute, Madame Sherri eventually ended up on public assistance in a nursing home outside of Brattleboro, VT. On October 20, 1965, Ann Stokes purchased the Chesterfield property. When she went to inform Madame about it, Madame's response was "Tell me something to make me happy." She died shortly afterward. Ann worked diligently to preserve the integrity of the land, holding it until 1998. Then, she transferred it to the New Hampshire Society for the Preservation of Forest, which still maintains it. Now, it is called Madame Sherri Forest. The foundation, chimneys and a grand stone staircase of the Castle can still be seen near the Forest’s Gulf Road entrance.
If you would like to learn more about Madame Sherri, visit the Chesterfield Historical Society to hear stories and see some of her memorabilia. Some of her stories can be found in the
Tales and Legend section.